Feudal structures in 21st century
India are indeed the best mechanisms to keep the nation in the 19th. And yes they have helped mediocrity to rule
the roost in both the political as well as bureaucratic arenas.
The Congress in the political and the Indian
Railways in the bureaucratic arenas are perhaps the finest living examples of a
cultural ethos rooted in a feudal and therefore sycophantic environment. Though
there are many more examples in both arenas, but none as feudal and therefore
as sycophantic as these two and their contribution in the national debacle is
therefore unmatched and worthy of appreciation.
Let us first look at the great Indian Railways,
great because it was one of the biggest achievements of the british raj, an
achievement that qualified to be cited as the economic lifeline of the nation
ever since. Unfortunately when the british left and our home grown rulers took
over, the feudal mindset of a ruler that regarded all others as slaves
continued. The bureaucratic structure continued and rapidly grew to be more
bureaucratic than ever, the reason being that the rulers soon realized that
self perpetuation is more fun than serving the masses. And so the culture of
saloons, personal attendants, big bungalows, gifts and graft blossomed with
time. Work took a back seat, only to be handled by the supervisory staff who
unfortunately were kept away from the loot that was always regarded as the
prerogative of the officer cadre. With
passage of time newer tools like Mahila Samities and protocol emerged to
further the cultural legacy of feudalism.
The mahila samities served as a convenient tool to massage the ego’s of
the memsahibs in the garb of welfare. Reception parties for receiving and
sending off senior officers moving on official and personal visits massaged
ego’s at the cost of spine.
Yes it is true that the railways of today has a
culture that encourages a very fine officer to convert to a leech by the time
he occupies apex level positions – and we have perfect examples at present.
Congress also belongs to the same mold.
Congressmen of various hues and mold have realized that sucking up to the first
family is perhaps the best means to retain and enjoy power. And so we have
odious comparisons to goddesses of someone who was not even born in this nation,
all for the sake of holding on to power for personal gains, the nation can go
to hell.
The
arrival of Modi on the scene may make a difference to the nation. The only
difference that one does not want to witness emerging is the culture of feudalism
and sycophancy in the party with a difference.
Saying this publicly requires a very sturdy spine. "Yes it is true that the railways of today has a culture that encourages a very fine officer to convert to a leech by the time he occupies apex level positions – and we have perfect examples at present. "
ReplyDelete1970-90's, railway absorbed bulk of Indias produce of grade A talent from IIT's, Roorkees and REC's.
Yet in 2000s we have seen more technology imports! This duality can only be explained by a culture that is not based on meritocracy, putting the finest minds of India (of 1970's to 90's) into an unquestioning mill. Without questioning - there cannot be better answers. From my experience working with railways- if you question- you are a troublemaker!